carry coals to newcastle
Britishto take goods to a place where there are already plenty of them; to supply something where it is not needed
In the movies · 1
Meaning
to take goods to a place where there are already plenty of them; to supply something where it is not needed
What it means
It means to supply something to a place that already has plenty of it, making the effort completely pointless. It describes an action or gift that is entirely redundant.
Related phrases & origin
When people say it
Speakers use this phrase to point out that an action, product, or service is useless because there is no need for it. As in the movie line, it often carries a wry or ironic tone to highlight a waste of effort.
Mostly British
This idiom comes from a British city and is far more common in British English than in American English.
Origin
Newcastle upon Tyne in north-east England was historically a major coal-mining and coal-exporting center. Shipping coal to a city that already produced vast amounts of it was the ultimate example of a pointless task.
Common mistake
Learners sometimes use the singular word 'coal', but the standard traditional idiom uses the plural 'coals'.
Learn it in full scenes
More idioms
Questions
- What does “carry coals to newcastle” mean?
- to take goods to a place where there are already plenty of them; to supply something where it is not needed
- How is “carry coals to newcastle” used?
- Speakers use this phrase to point out that an action, product, or service is useless because there is no need for it. As in the movie line, it often carries a wry or ironic tone to highlight a waste of effort.
- Which movies use “carry coals to newcastle”?
- You can hear it in The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp (1943).
- Where does “carry coals to newcastle” come from?
- Newcastle upon Tyne in north-east England was historically a major coal-mining and coal-exporting center. Shipping coal to a city that already produced vast amounts of it was the ultimate example of a pointless task.
With Pro you also get
- Unlimited any-language search · 200 AI breakdowns a day
- Bilingual YouTube subtitles, any length (free: 15 min)
- Download clips to replay offline · Card & Alipay
Same Vibe Across Movies & YouTube
“There's food. Call for coals. I will return tonight.”
“I just got to wait for that coal to deliver. And they're all going to run over there. So, I should just grab it. Move it closer. Easy. ONE MORE LEVEL.”
“We're just going to use up the rest of that coal. We're going to make some torches and we're going to get going. Shall we? Shall we do it? Let's do it. Let's do it.”
“Saturday three points up at Newcastle would be a big statement of intent and it would certainly show the direction we want to go in and and help us start getting a wee bit of momentum. Well these evening games must be still a bit painful you because I've spoken to one of your brothers I'm not revealing what source but they tell me you used to record Coronation Street and then go back and watch it.”