be the judge of

formal

To claim or hand over the right to decide or evaluate something, often brushing aside someone else's view.

15 movies489 YouTube videos · 277 channels

1 / 8

I'll be the judge of what I must do, Mr. Ness.

The Untouchables (1987)

In the movies · 15

Watch it in all 15 movies

Meaning

  1. Editorial100% of films

    To claim or hand over the right to decide or evaluate something, often brushing aside someone else's view.

    • I'll be the judge of what I must do, Mr. Ness.

Phrase guide

A closer look at this phrase

To be the judge of something means to form your own opinion or make a decision for yourself rather than taking someone else's word for it. It usually carries a skeptical, firm, or assertive tone when someone else makes a bold claim. In everyday conversation, it most commonly appears in set patterns such as 'let me be the judge of that' or 'I will be the judge of that.'

What it actually means

  • Deciding or assessing for oneself

    Used when an individual insists on evaluating facts or making the final choice personally instead of letting another person decide.

    Let me be the judge of that.

When you'd say it

  • Responding to an exaggerated claim or recommendation

    A colleague or friend promises that an idea or product is flawless, and you want to test it yourself before believing them.

    Let me be the judge of that.

    From Two Weeks Notice (2002)
  • Pushing back against someone telling you how to act

    Someone tries to dictate your professional obligations, and you firmly establish that you answer only to your own conscience and duties.

    I'll be the judge of what I must do, Mr. Ness.

    From The Untouchables (1987)
  • Challenging an unauthorized arbiter of taste

    A person acts as if their personal standards define what is attractive or worthy, prompting others to question their authority.

    Who made him the judge of "hot"?

    From This Is 40 (2012) →

More ways to use it

  1. Lapikas says they didn't dumb it down in his talk but I think we get to be the judge of that.

    Using 'get to be the judge' highlights the audience's entitlement to make their own critical assessment.

    From hbomberguy →
  2. I'll be the judge of what I must do, Mr. Ness.

    The modal contraction 'I'll' signals a firm, formal boundary during a direct conflict.

    From The Untouchables (1987)
  3. I'll be the judge of that. Come on, let's go.

    This rapid spoken reaction expresses immediate willingness to inspect the claim on the spot.

    From Topper Guild →
  4. You may think the recipe is simple, but let me be the judge of that when I cook it.

    Pairing the idiom with a conditional clause softens the challenge into a playful test.

Common mistakes

  • Let me be judge of that.Let me be the judge of that.

    Learners often omit the definite article, but the idiom requires 'the' before 'judge'.

  • I will be the judge about what happens next.I will be the judge of what happens next.

    The noun 'judge' in this construction always takes the preposition 'of', not 'about' or 'for'.

Similar & opposite phrases

Similar phrases

  • judge for oneself
  • decide for oneself

Learn it in full scenes

Questions

What does “be the judge of” mean?
To claim or hand over the right to decide or evaluate something, often brushing aside someone else's view.
How is “be the judge of” used?
Commonly heard in phrases like 'Let me be the judge of that' or 'I'll be the judge of that.' Speakers use it when they want to assert control, show skepticism, or push back against someone who is telling them what to think.
Which movies use “be the judge of”?
You can hear it in 6 Underground (2019), Broadcast News (1987), The Basketball Diaries (1995) and more (15 movies in total).
What are other ways to say “be the judge of”?
judge for oneself, decide for oneself

With Pro you also get

  • Unlimited any-language search · 200 AI breakdowns a day
  • Bilingual YouTube subtitles, any length (free: 15 min)
  • Download clips to replay offline · Card & Alipay
From $7.99/mo — see Pro →