00:00 / 01:39
00:00 / 01:39

Robby Confronts Macleish, Explained

Spotlight · 2015

Capítulo 12 de 21 · 1'39"

Robby corners the lawyer Eric Macleish in a parking lot and refuses to take no for an answer: "the hell he can't." He lays out the choice - a story about "degenerate clergy" or one about lawyers turning abuse into a "cottage industry" - and asks which the paper should write.

AccusationsThreatsThreateningConfrontingRivalsC1fastamerican

Key moments

Start here, then watch the full scene
  1. ❝ Monólogo · 5 frases Which Story Do You Want?

    0:37–1:02
    25s
  1. ❝ MonólogoRobby's two-story ultimatum5 frasesPracticar ↗

Robby Confronts Macleish, explained

What happens

In a parking lot, the reporters catch up with the lawyer Eric Macleish, who says he is too busy to talk. Robby refuses to accept it and tells him that if he does not hand over the names of priests and victims, the paper will run one of two stories: corrupt clergy, or lawyers profiting from abuse.

What's really going on

The parking lot is the point: no office, no appointment, no escape. Robby's opening line, "the hell he can't," sets the tone - this is not an interview but a shakedown with a deadline. What makes it work is that the threat is framed as a choice, not a threat: "which story do you want us to write?" The two options are both damaging, one aimed at the Church and one at Macleish's own profession, so silence is not a safe answer. Macleish's counter is the real wound: he claims he already sent a list of names years ago and the paper buried it, which turns the confrontation into an indictment of the Globe itself.

Key lines & what they mean

“Now, which story do you want us to write?”
The ultimatum in question form: cooperate, or the paper prints the version that hurts you.
“'Cause we're writing one of them.”
The line that closes the choice: there is no option in which nothing gets published.
“So I sent you guys a list of names, and you buried it.”
Macleish's counterattack, accusing the Globe of having ignored his list years earlier.
“I want those names tomorrow.”
Robby's deadline, turning the confrontation into a demand with a clock on it.

Theme

  • Corruption — The scene shows how abuse became business, with lawyers and the Church each protecting their own interests.
  • Power — Robby uses the paper's leverage as a threat, trading one damaging story for the names he needs.

Qué aprendes en este capítulo

Puntos de enseñanza

Repasa justo después de ver
Mi nivel1/4

A1–C2 es la escala MCER. Las tarjetas por encima del nivel elegido se atenúan y la reproducción no se pausa en ellas.

Spotlight: tu progreso

Capítulo 12 de 21 · quedan unos 25 min

← Anterior
Siguiente · 13from the top downLa escena: The Team Goes After the System

Preguntas frecuentes

La pregunta, luego la frase
Why do the reporters confront Macleish in a parking lot?

He is too busy to meet them anywhere else, so they catch him on his way, refusing to accept his brush-off.

What are the two stories Robby offers?

One is about degenerate clergy, the other about lawyers who turned child abuse into a lucrative cottage industry - both damaging, whichever gets printed.

What does Macleish accuse the Globe of?

He says he sent a list of names to the paper years ago and it buried the story, which is why he could not pursue the cases without the press.

Is Robby threatening Macleish?

It is a pressure tactic framed as a choice: give up the names of priests and victims, or the paper runs one of two damaging stories.