00:00 / 02:42
00:00 / 02:42

Enron's Dabhol Plant in Ruins, Explained

Enron sells itself as a stable company with profits rising every year, and as the firm that built a power plant in India when others were terrified. Under the pitch, profits are headed the other way, India cannot pay for the power, and the site is already a ruin. "Now Dabhol is a ruin."

SpeechesStorytellingPersuadingExplainingC1mediumamericanClean

Key moments

Start here, then watch the full scene
  1. The Stable Pitch Meets Falling Profits

    1:06–1:41
    35s
  2. Bonuses on a Plant Left in Ruins

    2:02–2:40
    38s

Enron's Dabhol Plant in Ruins, explained

What happens

Viewers hear Enron's sales pitch: newest markets, a taste for risk, and profits said to rise every year. The story then turns to a power plant in India. Dabhol's first phase is generating power and the second is under construction, but India cannot pay for that power. The plant is now a ruin, the project lost a billion dollars, and bonuses still go out on profits that never arrived.

What's really going on

The pitch sells Enron as something new: people at ease with change, markets opening up, and an "Enron on-line" story called fabulous. They were so good at their acting that they convinced corporate America they were smarter than anyone else. The company is still sold as a stable place that can lift profits ten to fifteen percent a year. Hitting those numbers meant questionable things and enormous risk. "We like risk. Because you make money by taking risk." In the India pitch, Dabhol is a great year, phase one generating power and phase two under construction. Someone with experience calls India a place you assiduously stayed away from, and others were terrified of investing there. Enron did it "in a big way," then missed something basic. "India couldn't afford to pay for the power Enron's plant produced." "Now Dabhol is a ruin." A billion dollars is lost, and bonuses rest on "imaginary profits that never arrived."

Key lines & what they mean

“They were so good at their acting that they convinced corporate America that they were smarter than anyone else.”
Calling it acting means the pitch was a performance, and it convinced corporate America that Enron was smarter than anyone else.
“But in reality, profits weren't going up; they were headed in the opposite direction.”
Right after the claim that Enron was soaring, this line says profits were not rising at all. They were moving the other way.
“Enron did it, and did it in a big way.”
Others would not build in India. Enron did, and "in a big way" here means on a very large scale.
“India couldn't afford to pay for the power Enron's plant produced.”
This is the basic fact Enron failed to see. India could not pay for the electricity the plant produced.
“Enron paid out multi-million dollar bonuses to executives based on imaginary profits that never arrived.”
The project had lost a billion dollars, yet executives still received multi-million dollar bonuses. The profits used to justify that pay never arrived.

Theme

  • Deception — Enron is sold as new and stably profitable while profits run the other way and its India plant is already a ruin.
  • Money — A billion-dollar loss on Dabhol does not stop multi-million-dollar bonuses paid on profits that never arrived.

Qué aprendes en este capítulo

Puntos de enseñanza

Repasa justo después de ver
Mi nivel0/8

A1–C2 es la escala MCER. Las tarjetas por encima del nivel elegido se atenúan y la reproducción no se pausa en ellas.

Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room: tu progreso

Capítulo 1 de 3 · quedan unos 5 min

Siguiente · 02both sides of the transactionLa escena: Fastow Admits Both Sides

Preguntas frecuentes

La pregunta, luego la frase
Why is Dabhol described as a ruin?

India could not afford to pay for the power Enron's plant produced. The next line states the outcome: "Now Dabhol is a ruin." The project lost a billion dollars.

Were Enron's profits actually going up?

The company was sold as a stable place that could raise profits 10 to 15 percent a year, and by all accounts it was soaring. In reality, profits were not going up; they were headed in the opposite direction. Reaching those numbers meant questionable things and enormous risks.

How were bonuses paid on a project that lost a billion dollars?

The narration puts the two facts side by side. The project lost a billion dollars, and Enron still paid multi-million dollar bonuses to executives based on imaginary profits that never arrived.

Why does the narration call Enron's pitch acting?

Because that performance convinced corporate America that Enron was smarter than anyone else. Just before the line, the company is fixated on its stock price and a public-relations campaign, recruits are promised the newest thinking and the newest markets, and "Enron on-line" is called a fabulous story.