5 to 7 · 2014 — Chapter 9 of 10 · 4'07" · B2

Brian Proposes to Arielle, Explained: talk you off the ledge

Brian calls his editor at midnight for jewelry advice, then proposes to Arielle, who is already married. "Not just from 5 to 7," he insists - he wants the whole life, not the scheduled hours. She reminds him, "We had a trust that you have now broken."

What happens

At midnight, Brian phones his editor to ask where to buy Arielle jewelry, admitting he is spotty on women's accessories. Then he goes to Arielle and proposes, saying he does not want to be just her 5-to-7 companion. He gives her a ring that is not a conventional engagement ring, even though she is married.

ProposalsConfessing feelingsConfessing loveAskingCoupleB2slowamericanClean
IMDb ↗

Listen for

talk you off the ledgeOkie-dokieoverratedconquest of the marketplace

00:00 / 04:07
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
  1. ❝ MonologueThe speech before the proposal5 linesPractice page ↗
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

talk you off the ledge

calm someone from a crisis

Jane defines their bond as late-night panic calls where she talks him down from the edge.

I can talk you off the ledge if you call me tonight.

Also in this scene

  • Okie-dokie

    all right then

  • overrated

    not as good as claimed

  • conquest of the marketplace

    winning over the market

  • play by the rules

    follow the rules

  • a dollar figure

    an exact amount in money

Everything marked in this scene

26 notes across 56 lines

Phrase · B2
be spotty on something

patchy about a topic

Because I'm spotty on women's accessories.
Phrase · A2
in the middle of the night

late at night

The kind where you call me in the middle of the night asking me crazy questions and I talk you off the ledge.
Phrase · C1
talk someone off the ledge

calm someone from a crisis

Jane defines their bond as late-night panic calls where she talks him down from the edge.

The kind where you call me in the middle of the night asking me crazy questions and I talk you off the ledge.
Grammar · B2
where you call me in the middle of the night

relative clause: The where-clause describes the kind of relationship, standing in for in which.

The kind where you call me in the middle of the night asking me crazy questions and I talk you off the ledge.
Sound
middle of the

Weak of and the blur into one light syllable after middle.

The kind where you call me in the middle of the night asking me crazy questions and I talk you off the ledge.
Phrase · B1
a dollar figure

an exact amount in money

Jane cuts through the vague talk and demands a dollar figure before naming a store.

Give me a dollar figure.
Phrase · A2
including tax

tax included

$6000, including tax.
Slang · B1
Okie-dokie

all right then — A cutesy way to close a chat; too childish for formal use.

Okie-dokie, then.
Grammar · B2
it were tomorrow

subjunctive wish: Wish plus were marks an unreal wish: it is not tomorrow at five yet.

I wish it were tomorrow at 5.
Sound
wish it were

Run wish it together and glide into were without a pause.

I wish it were tomorrow at 5.
Phrase · B1
mean something to someone

matter to a person

Brian says he wants to write stories that mean something to people, setting up the confession that follows.

And tell stories that mean something to people.
Phrase · A2
the only thing is ...

the single thing

But the only thing...
Phrase · B2
walk beside someone

stay at someone's side

is to be the man who walks beside you.
Sound
walks beside you

Link beside and you smoothly, almost 'by-side-ya'.

is to be the man who walks beside you.
Phrase · A2
not just ...

not merely

- You do walk beside me. - Not just from 5 to 7.
Phrase · A2
marry me

be my spouse

Marry me, Arielle. I wanna be your husband.
Phrase · B2
a conventional engagement ring

a standard engagement ring

And that's why this is not a conventional engagement ring.
Phrase · C1
a conquest of the marketplace

winning over the market

Brian jokes that a traditional ring would demand a full campaign through the market.

That and the fact that a conventional engagement ring will require a somewhat more robust conquest of the marketplace.
Phrase · B1
no longer do something

not anymore

I do and I can no longer play by them.
Phrase · B2
break a trust

betray confidence

We had a trust that you have now broken.
Phrase · B1
can't help it

cannot stop myself

And I can't help it.
Phrase · B1
spend one's life with someone

share a whole life with

I've found the person I wanna spend my life with.
Phrase · B1
a set of rules

a group of rules

That is a drive much stronger than any set of rules or any doubts about the meaning and purpose of marriage.
Grammar · B1
as strong as mine

as ... as comparison: As strong as mine compares the two feelings, with mine standing for my feelings.

Of course, if your... feelings aren't as strong as mine then... I completely understand.
Phrase · B1
from the first moment

right from the start

From the first moment.
Phrase · A2
in a hurry

quickly, rushed

You will be growing up in a very big hurry skipping your young adulthood.

Brian Proposes to Arielle, explained

What's really going on

Everything here is about a bargain changing shape. The midnight call shows Brian treating his editor as a lifeline - "I talk you off the ledge" - even as he plans a gift for another woman. With Arielle, he stops bargaining and asks for the whole thing: "Marry me, Arielle. I wanna be your husband," he says, and "Not just from 5 to 7. It's not enough. Not nearly." The trap is that she already has a signed life. When she answers "I am already married," he shows he knew all along; what he is rejecting is the rule, not the fact. Her line - "We had a trust that you have now broken" - reframes his love as a breach, and "You know the rules" turns the affair into a contract he has violated.

Theme

RomanceBrian turns a scheduled affair into a marriage proposal, choosing love over the arrangement that made it possible.
MarriageHe proposes to a married woman, forcing the question of what marriage means and whether their rules can hold.

What you'll learn

  • Marry me is the plainest possible proposal.
  • Talk someone off the ledge means calm a crisis call.
  • Not just from 5 to 7 refuses a time-limited affair.
  • Play by the rules names the code he is about to break.

Listen for

  • middle of the — Weak of and the blur into one light syllable after middle.
  • wish it were — Run wish it together and glide into were without a pause.
  • walks beside you — Link beside and you smoothly, almost 'by-side-ya'.
Marry me, Arielle. I wanna be your husband.

The proposal in one line: he asks her to marry him and names the role he wants, stepping out of the affair and into a life together.

- You do walk beside me. - Not just from 5 to 7.

His refusal to stay inside the arrangement: walking beside her only during the set hours is not enough for him.

I've found the person I wanna spend my life with.

His reason for breaking the rules: he says he has found the person he wants to share his whole life with.

It's not enough. Not nearly.

His answer to the limited hours of the affair - the time they are allowed is far too little for what he wants.

Questions about this scene

Why does Brian propose to Arielle if he knows she is married?

Because he wants more than the 5-to-7 affair and believes love outweighs the arrangement. He says the drive to be with her is stronger than any rules or doubts about marriage.

Why does Arielle say Brian broke their trust?

The affair came with rules: fixed hours and no threat to her marriage. By proposing, he broke that understanding, which she calls a trust he has now broken.

Why does Brian call his editor in the middle of the night?

He is flustered about buying Arielle jewelry and admits he is spotty on women's accessories, so he calls the person he trusts for late-night advice. She is his editor and his steadying friend.

Why is the ring not a conventional engagement ring?

Because Arielle is already married, so a standard engagement ring would be impossible. Brian gives what he can afford, acknowledging the situation with a wry joke.

What does Arielle mean by "You know the rules"?

She means the terms of their affair: the set 5-to-7 hours and the promise not to disturb her marriage. She is checking that he understood the deal before it goes any further.

5 to 7 · 10 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 9 of 10 · about 3 min to go