who's to say
informalused to say that something might happen or might have happened in a particular way, because nobody really knows
In the movies · 7
Real voices across 1,315 YouTube videos
Meaning
who's to say (…)?
used to say that something might happen or might have happened in a particular way, because nobody really knows
Who's to say we would not have succeeded if we'd had more time?
Phrase guide
A closer look at this phrase
"Who's to say" is an informal spoken idiom used to suggest that something is possible because nobody really knows for certain. It carries an open-minded or gently skeptical tone, reminding listeners that the future or past cannot be proven definitively. Since it functions as a rhetorical question, speakers use it to state an opinion rather than to ask for an actual answer.
What it actually means
Expressing Uncertainty About What Might Happen or Be True
Used to suggest that an outcome or explanation is entirely possible because nobody possesses enough proof to rule it out.
Who's to say what the market will look like in five years?
When you'd say it
Debating Distant History
Two people are discussing an event that happened long ago where records are unclear, and one points out that nobody alive today can be certain.
No, it was 100 years ago. Who's to say?
From BlackBerry (2023)Speculating on an Upcoming Decision
A commentator talks about two closely matched candidates before an election where the outcome remains unpredictable.
Well that blank could be Clinton or Bob Dole and who's to say which one until tomorrow?
From Vsauce →Raising a Plausible Hidden Risk
A presenter discusses tech security and points out that an unseen threat could easily exist without anyone knowing.
In fact, who's to say that there aren't already state spies working as paid software engineers at some of the larger companies putting in exactly backdoors like this?
From Veritasium →
More ways to use it
No, it was 100 years ago. Who's to say?
Here the phrase stands on its own as a short rhetorical response to close a debate about the unprovable past.
From BlackBerry (2023)Well that blank could be Clinton or Bob Dole and who's to say which one until tomorrow?
Connected with a wh-clause ('which one') to emphasize that no one has the authority or foresight to declare a winner early.
From Vsauce →- Who's to say that?
Used as a direct conversational pushback to question who has the right or authority to make such a claim.
From Sidemen →It looks difficult right now, but who's to say you won't succeed?
Introduces a rhetorical clause to offer encouragement by highlighting that the future remains open.
Common mistakes
Whose to say what will happen tomorrow?Who's to say what will happen tomorrow?
Use the contraction 'who's' (meaning 'who is'), not the possessive adjective 'whose'.
Who is saying that we cannot try again?Who's to say that we cannot try again?
The idiomatic pattern requires 'who's to say' rather than the continuous form 'who is saying' when questioning whether something is impossible.
Similar & opposite phrases
Similar phrases
- who knows
- there's no telling
- hard to say
Opposite
- it's safe to say
- there's no doubt
From the same entry
More idioms
Questions
- What does “who's to say” mean?
- used to say that something might happen or might have happened in a particular way, because nobody really knows
- How is “who's to say” used?
- People use it in conversations when discussing past events, future possibilities, or subjective opinions where there is no definitive answer. As in the movie *BlackBerry*, it is often used to shrug off debate and accept uncertainty.
- Which movies use “who's to say”?
- You can hear it in BlackBerry (2023), Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban (2004), Moonrise Kingdom (2012) and more (7 movies in total).
- What are other ways to say “who's to say”?
- who knows, there's no telling, hard to say
With Pro you also get
- Unlimited any-language search · 200 AI breakdowns a day
- Bilingual YouTube subtitles, any length (free: 15 min)
- Download clips to replay offline · Card & Alipay
Definitions from the Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary, 9th edition
Same Vibe Across Movies & YouTube
“And it is a tie. Do we find out who said anything?”
“Says who? Do you know? I don't know.”
“Who says who? He knows the voice. Believe me.”
“Listen, if this is who's going to be the guy, we got to figure this out. I'm going to figure this out. But you have to tell me if this is going to be the guy. Mhm.”