I can buy two dozen of these cigarette boxes at Miklos Brothers. What do you think of it?The Shop Around the Corner · 1940 — 第 3 / 19 章 · 2'23" · B2
Matuschek's Singing Cigarette Box, Explained:make up your mind
Matuschek wants to stock a cigarette box that plays 'Ochi Tchornya,' and asks his staff for an honest opinion. One employee flatters him, another hedges; Kralik gives real reasons to say no. But it isn't about leather and glue — it's about who may disagree with the boss. 'You just sell things and let me do the buying, huh?'
あらすじ
In Matuschek's Budapest shop, the owner brings out a cigarette box that plays 'Ochi Tchornya' and wants his clerks' verdict. Vadas calls it sensational; Novak says anyone who smokes and likes the tune will approve. Kralik alone objects: at twenty cigarettes a day, the customer would hear the song twenty times a day, and the imitation leather will fall apart. Matuschek phones the supplier and cancels.
注目の表現
make up your mindnot quite sure aboutfall apartin reference to
このシーンの表現
make up your mind
to decide firmly
克拉利克刚把烟盒贬得一文不值,马图谢克当着众人夸他拿主意快,这句话是反着说的。
You should make up your mind before we book the tickets.
このシーンの他の表現
- not quite sure about
to be not entirely certain about something
- fall apart
to break into pieces or collapse
- in reference to
regarding or concerning something
このシーンのメモ一覧
47 行のセリフに 34 件のメモ
liaison
But you haven't listened to it. It plays "Ochi Tchornya."Well, even if it played Beethoven's Ninth Symphony I'd still say no. No, I just don't like the idea.Well, even if it played Beethoven's Ninth Symphony I'd still say no. No, I just don't like the idea.to decide firmly
It's wonderful the way you can make up your mind so quickly.I've been in this business for 35 years.It took me a whole hour to decide that I like this box.it takes someone time to do something
It took me a whole hour to decide that I like this box.But, of course, you're a genius.You know so much more than I.- Yes, Mr. Matuschek? - Look here.Now, I want your honest opinion.'All I want is your honest opinion.'I think it's sensational!Yeah, well, Mr. Kralik have you thought it over?Well, give me one reason!let's say for a hypothetical
Well, let's say that a man smokes 20 cigarettes a day.That means that 20 times a day he has to open this box and 20 times a day he has to listen to "Ochi Tchornya."It's a perfectly terrible idea.And besides, it's imitation leather,to break into pieces or collapse
the glue's no good in two weeks the whole thing will fall apart and all you'll have left is "Ochi Tchornya."the glue's no good in two weeks the whole thing will fall apart and all you'll have left is "Ochi Tchornya."don't have to for lack of necessity
You don't have to tell me that-that-that it's imitation leather. I know that.weak form
You just sell things and let me do the buying, huh?You just sell things and let me do the buying, huh?regarding or concerning something
Excuse me, Mr. Matuschek. Miklos Brothers on the telephone in reference to the cigarette box.Can I call you back in about five minutes? I.....I'd like a little more time to think about it.liaison
...I'd like a little more time to think about it.It's just that I-I'm not quite sure about the whole idea.You can't expect me to make up my mind in five minutes!expect someone to do something
You can't expect me to make up my mind in five minutes!Well, if that's the case, then I'll have to say no.Well, if that's the case, then I'll have to say no.「Matuschek's Singing Cigarette Box」を読み解く
What's really going on
Matuschek asks for an honest opinion, but what he wants is agreement. He pre-empts dissent by announcing that he has been in this business for 35 years, and when Kralik argues against the box, he cuts him off: 'You just sell things and let me do the buying, huh?' The shop works like a small court. One clerk, angling for favor, calls the box sensational; another stays safely noncommittal. Kralik's objection is the only one built on facts — twenty openings a day, cheap glue, imitation leather — and the only one that costs him something. Matuschek hangs up on the supplier saying no, but the point is already clear: the opinions were never the question, the hierarchy was.
Theme
このチャプターで学べること
- Use make up your mind to talk about deciding.
- Hear think it over as a request for time.
- Use even if…still… to hold your position.
- Use fall apart for a product that breaks down.
発音のポイント
- listened to — liaison
- do the — weak form
- about it — liaison
Well, even if it played Beethoven's Ninth Symphony I'd still say no. No, I just don't like the idea.A flat refusal. Even Beethoven's Ninth couldn't sell him on it, and he won't dress the no up as economics — he simply dislikes the whole idea.
It's wonderful the way you can make up your mind so quickly.A sarcastic compliment: admiration for how fast Matuschek decided, aimed at a man who claimed to need time and an hour just to pick a box he liked.
Well, if that's the case, then I'll have to say no.Matuschek's exit line on the phone: if the supplier won't give him time to think, the answer is no. It mirrors the pressure he puts on his own clerks.
It's a perfectly terrible idea.Kralik's verdict after doing the math: twenty cigarettes a day means twenty hearings of the tune. A few words, and the scheme is dead.
このシーンについての質問
Why does Matuschek ask for opinions if he has already decided?
He wants the decision to feel like the staff's, and he wants to hear agreement. The moment Kralik disagrees, Matuschek's line — 'You just sell things and let me do the buying' — shows the opinion was never really up for debate.
Is Kralik right to object to the cigarette box?
His reasoning is sound: a twenty-a-day smoker would hear the tune twenty times a day, and cheap glue on imitation leather would fail within weeks. The scene lets him be both right and out of line with his boss.
Who is Miklos in this scene?
Miklos Brothers is the supplier offering the cigarette boxes, not a character in the shop. Matuschek calls them back, asks for more time, then declines the order — the box that nearly started an argument is never bought.
How does the phone call change things?
Matuschek asks Miklos Brothers for five more minutes, then bristles at being rushed. When the supplier presses him, he says no — the same impatience he showed Kralik, now turned against him.
桃色の店 · 全 19 章
すべて見る →
次のチャプター · 第 4 章go through the whole routineA Job Seeker's Sales Pitch
第 1 章make something out of nothingMorning Gossip at Matuschek's
第 2 章earn one's daily breadThe Anonymous Letter From Box 237
再生中 · 第 3 章make up your mindMatuschek's Singing Cigarette Box
第 4 章go through the whole routineA Job Seeker's Sales Pitch
第 5 章have a weakness forSelling the Musical Candy Box
第 6 章knock on woodKralik Reveals His Pen Pal
第 7 章pick on someoneMatuschek Turns on Kralik
第 8 章call it a dayKlara Asks Kralik for a Night Off
第 9 章of one's own accordMatuschek Fires Kralik
第 10 章mind your own businessMatuschek Learns of the Affair
第 11 章had enough bad news for todayKralik's Blind Date Is Miss Novak
第 12 章instead of a heart, a handbagKralik and Novak Meet at the Cafe
第 13 章kept in strictest confidenceMatuschek Confesses His Jealousy
第 14 章a yes manKralik Fires Vadas
第 15 章not in the same planetKralik Visits a Sick Klara
第 16 章ruin ChristmasThe Staff Choose Christmas Gifts
第 17 章from the bottom of my heartMatuschek Returns on Christmas Eve
第 18 章your whole life ahead of youMatuschek Invites a Lonely Boy Home
第 19 章swept me off my feetKlara Confesses to Kralik