Brandon Asks About Willoughby, Explained

What happens

In London, Colonel Brandon calls on Elinor and asks her once and for all whether Marianne and Willoughby are settled. Elinor says she has no doubt of their mutual affection. Brandon wishes Marianne every imaginable happiness, then says of Willoughby only that he hopes he may endeavour to deserve her.

What's really going on

The chapter hides its real subject inside politeness. Brandon has come because he has heard reports, and the question he is finally brave enough to ask — 'Is everything finally resolved between your sister and Mr. Willoughby?' — is the question of a man who has already been hurt by the answer. Elinor gives him the conventional assurance, that she has no doubt of their mutual affection, and for a moment he accepts it. Then comes the line that gives him away: 'To your sister, I wish all imaginable happiness.' and, of Willoughby, 'that he may endeavour to deserve her.' It is the most delicate warning in the film, since it pretends to be a blessing. Elinor notices at once and asks what he means, but the scene lets the implication stand without explanation. Brandon knows something about Willoughby, and he will not say it aloud.

Key lines & what they mean

“Don't talk to me of coals.”

Mrs. Jennings's impatient answer to a practical reminder, the first sign of her flustered, self-interested mood.

“John and Fanny are in town. I think we shall be forced to see them.”

The line that sets up the social entanglement of London, where the Dashwoods cannot avoid relatives they would rather not meet.

“There you are, Pooter. Still alive, I see.”

A teasing greeting, using still alive as a joke rather than a real inquiry.

“Is everything finally resolved between your sister and Mr. Willoughby?”

Brandon's blunt question, asked once and for all, which reveals how much he has been thinking about Marianne.

“To your sister, I wish all imaginable happiness.”

His generous wish for Marianne, sincere and painful at the same time.

“In good order, ma'am, though I might suggest the ordering of coal.”

The servant's careful reply, practical business delivered under Mrs. Jennings's impatience.

Theme

• Romance — Brandon's careful question shows he already knows the answer, and his blessing for Willoughby carries a warning.
• Heartbreak — He wishes Marianne happiness while doubting the man she loves, taking no comfort for himself.