“Well, I don't want to be relied on.”
Why it's great
It takes a heavy burden of trust and sets it down without a fight.
Register
Neutral
Use it yourself
I don't want to be relied on for every decision.
00:00 / 04:22
00:00 / 04:22
Lucy Rents the Haunted House, Explained
The Ghost and Mrs. Muir · 1947
Chapter 3 of 18 · 4'22"
Mr. Coombe is trying to talk Lucy out of Gull Cottage: four sets of tenants, four first-night flights. "Haunted. How perfectly fascinating," she says, and the landlord's scare tactic is suddenly the selling point. His warning that she is the most obstinate woman he has ever met only seals her decision.
Key moments
Start here, then watch the full scene- 1:08–1:57
Lucy Takes the Haunted House
49s
Lucy Rents the Haunted House, explained
What happens
Lucy Muir tours Gull Cottage with the letting agent, Mr. Coombe, who has had enough of the place: four tenants in a row fled after a single night. Lucy finds the ghost story charming rather than frightening, returns, and announces she will take the cottage. When Coombe calls her obstinate, she takes it as a compliment.
What's really going on
On the surface this is a transaction: will Lucy rent the house nobody keeps? Underneath, it is Lucy choosing a life. She is a young widow with little money and less say in her own affairs, and Gull Cottage is the one thing no one else wants, which makes it the one thing she can claim. Coombe's warnings, meant to protect her, only prove the point: "I never want to see this house again," he says of the place, while she insists on walking back into it. When he finally calls her "the most obstinate young woman I have ever met," he thinks he is insulting her; she answers, "I've always wanted to be considered obstinate." Her defiance is not recklessness so much as a first assertion of will: she is not taking the house in spite of the ghost, she is taking it because the ghost is the only thing standing in her way.
Key lines & what they mean
- “Well, I don't want to be relied on.”
- Lucy refuses the burden the absent landlord is quietly handing her: she will not be the dependable one who has to hold everything together.
- “I never want to see this house again.”
- Coombe's verdict on Gull Cottage after four failed tenancies: he has given up on it and wishes he could walk away.
- “But it's too ridiculous, really, in the 20th century, to believe in apparitions and all that medieval nonsense.”
- Lucy dismisses ghosts as superstition unworthy of a modern woman, exactly the rational pose that will be tested the moment she moves in.
- “I've always wanted to be considered obstinate.”
- Coombe means "obstinate" as an insult; Lucy calmly pockets it as a compliment and a declaration of independence.
- “I have nothing to show for all my years.”
- Martha's quiet lament that a lifetime of cooking and housework has left her with nothing she can point to as her own.
- “In my opinion, you are the most obstinate young woman I have ever met.”
- Coombe's exasperated surrender: he cannot talk her out of the house, so he names the trait that defeated him.
Theme
- Courage — Lucy chooses the house everyone else flees from, turning a ghost story into the first decision she makes for herself.
- Identity — Coombe's "obstinate" is meant as an insult, but Lucy claims it: "I've always wanted to be considered obstinate."
What this chapter teaches
Teaching points
Review right after watchingMy level2/7
A1–C2 is the CEFR scale. Cards above the level you pick fade, and playback will not auto-pause on them.
Language points
Click a card to jump to its moment in the videoGolden lines
A great line in its own right — why and how to use it“I never want to see this house again.”
Why it's great
Never with again closes the door on the house for good.
Register
Informal
Use it yourself
I never want to see that office again.
“But it's too ridiculous, really, in the 20th century, to believe in apparitions and all that medieval nonsense.”
Why it's great
Filing ghosts under the Middle Ages is how she talks herself out of fear.
Register
Informal
Use it yourself
It's ridiculous to believe in lucky numbers.
“I've always wanted to be considered obstinate.”
Why it's great
She collects an insult and wears it as a badge, which ends the argument.
Register
Informal
Use it yourself
I've always wanted to be considered stubborn.
“I have nothing to show for all my years.”
Why it's great
The quiet word nothing carries a whole lifetime of regret.
Register
Neutral
Use it yourself
I have nothing to show for a decade of work.
“In my opinion, you are the most obstinate young woman I have ever met.”
Why it's great
The superlative sounds like a verdict, but it is really an admission of defeat.
Register
Formal
Use it yourself
You are the most patient person I have ever met.
Up next · 04spunkThe scene: Lucy Meets Captain Gregg's GhostTakeaways
What you walk away with- Fear and delight trade places in one word: fascinating.
- Refusing to be relied on is its own quiet rebellion.
- A sailor's phrase slips out and gives a secret away.
- Coombe loses every round and keeps his manners.
People also search
Questions, then the linesWhy does Mr. Coombe keep warning Lucy about the house?
He has rented it out four times and every tenant has left after the very first night. He is not being cruel; he genuinely expects her to fail and wants no responsibility when she does.
Is Lucy right to take Gull Cottage?
The film treats it as her first real act of independence. Nobody else wants the house, so nobody can stop her from having it, and its bad reputation becomes the privacy she has been missing.
What does "fiddlesticks" mean here?
It is an old-fashioned way of saying "nonsense." Coombe uses it to brush aside Lucy's wind-in-the-chimney explanation: polite wording, flat disbelief.
Why does Lucy insist on being called Mrs. Muir?
She has just become a widow and is holding on to her standing as a married woman rather than being treated as a girl. The title is her way of asking for respect.
What is the understanding Coombe makes before handing over the house?
He lets her take Gull Cottage on the condition that he takes no responsibility for whatever happens there, a face-saving exit since he is sure the ghost will drive her out.