Chapter 8 of 18 · 7'39"
Testimony Through Noise 听不见的证词IMDb ↗
关键证词经不起一次安静推演
12-angry-men-1957 · 1957
Learning settings
The story so far
Everything you need before watchingThe jurors revisit two pieces of testimony and time the passage of an elevated train. If the train took ten seconds to clear the window, its roar may have covered the threat the old man claimed to hear. The debate then turns inward: could a lonely, overlooked witness have convinced himself that he heard and saw more than he really did?
Chapters
18 parts · AI-cutTranscript
Language points
Click a card to jump to its moment in the videoTeaching points
Review right after watchingget down to business
开始谈正事
talk into a dead phone
像对着坏电话说话
take a guess
猜猜看
punchy
疲惫而烦躁
at the top of one's lungs
扯着嗓子大喊
stand to reason
按道理说得通
lay someone out
把某人打趴下
bright sayings
自以为高明的话
Golden lines
A great line in its own right — why and how to use it“- You can hardly hear yourself think. - All right, you can't hear yourself think.”
你几乎连自己的想法都听不见。
用夸张而形象的说法表现噪音大到无法思考。
You can hardly hear yourself do something.
描述环境太吵、太乱,无法专心时。
It’s too noisy to think. / I can’t hear myself think.
informal
重读 hardly、hear、think,think 前稍停。
“It's not possible he could've heard it.”
他不可能听见那句话。
用简洁有力的句式否定证词的可信度,适合表达判断。
It’s not possible (that) someone could have done something.
根据条件或证据,明确表示某事不可能发生。
There’s no way he heard it. / He couldn’t possibly have heard it.
neutral
重读 not possible 和 heard,could've 弱读后连向 heard。
“Gentlemen, that's a very sad thing - to be nothing.”
先生们,默默无闻、一无是处,是件非常悲哀的事。
短句后置 to be nothing,形成停顿和沉重的哲理感。
That’s a very [形容词] thing—to [动词].
谈论某种处境或行为带来的深层感受时。
That’s a painful thing—to admit. / It’s a terrible thing to lose hope.
literary
Gentlemen 后停顿,sad 和 nothing 重读,结尾下沉。
Monologue
One character carrying the scene — shadow the whole passageIt was just that I looked at him for a very long time. The seams of his jacket was split, under the shoulder. Or did you notice that? I mean, to come to court like that. Why... He was a very old man in a torn jacket. And he walked very slowly to the stand. He was dragging his left leg and trying to hide it... because he was ashamed. I think I know this man better than anyone here. This is a quiet, frightened, insignificant old man who... who has been nothing all his life... who has never had recognition... or his name in the newspapers. Nobody knows him. Nobody quotes him. Gentlemen, that's a very sad thing - to be nothing. A man like this needs to be quoted, to be listened to. To be quoted just once. Very important to him. It would be so hard for him to recede into the background...
只是因为我盯着他看了很久。 他夹克肩膀下面的接缝裂开了。 你没注意到吗? 我是说,他就穿成那样来法庭。 为什么…… 他是个穿着破夹克的老人。 他走上证人席时,步子非常慢。 他拖着左腿,还在努力掩饰…… 因为他觉得丢脸。 我想,在座没人比我更了解这个人。 这是一个安静、害怕、微不足道的老人,他…… 他一辈子都无足轻重…… 从来没有得到过认可…… 报纸上也从来没有出现过他的名字。 没人认识他。 没人引用他的话。 先生们,默默无闻、一无是处,是件非常悲哀的事。 这样的人需要有人引用他的话,需要有人听他说话。 哪怕只被引用一次。 这对他来说非常重要。 要他重新退回到无人注意的角落,对他来说一定太难了……
